Michael Penix Jr. robbed of the Heisman: Fans, media sound off after all-time performance in CFP semifinal win
Michael Penix Jr. has the college football community re-litigating the Heisman Trophy after a dazzling performance in Washington’s College Football Playoff semifinal win over Texas.
The Huskies moved to 14-0 on the season with a 37-31 win over the Longhorns to advance to the CFP National Championship. In the game, Penix threw for 430 yards and two touchdowns while completing 29 of his 38 pass attempts. Penix kept Washington, which never trailed in the game, on the front foot all night as he threw dart after dart.
It was the kind of performance a player dreams of — an elite display on the biggest stage with a national championship on the line. Penix returned in 2023 to experience that exact moment, and when it arrived, he rose to the occasion.
That prompted many — fans and media alike — to once again question the decision to award the Heisman Trophy to LSU quarterback Jayden Daniels.
Penix finished second in Heisman voting. Daniels was named the winner on Dec. 9 after helping LSU to a 9-3 record.
During the regular season, Daniels threw for 3,812 yards, ran for 1,134 yards, and scored 50 total touchdowns He entered the bowl season as the FBS leader in Total QBR (95.7) and EPA (132.3). He became the only player in FBS history to pass for 12,000 yards and run for 3,000 yards in a career. Against Florida on Nov. 11, Daniels became the first quarterback in FBS history to throw for at least 350 yards and run for at least 200 yards in a single game.
The LSU passer had an outstanding individual season and was a deserving winner.
It just so happens that Penix also had an outstanding individual season and would have been a deserving winner.
And while Daniels sat out of the ReliaQuest Bowl, Penix led his team to a CFP semifinal win over Texas at the Sugar Bowl. Washington’s 14 wins are a program record for a season. Given Penix’s outsized role in that achievement, many believe the Heisman decision looks more like a snub now.
Michael Penix Jr. was all-time last night.
We’re going to re-litigate this year’s Heisman vote years from now.
— Josh Newman (@Joshua_Newman) January 2, 2024
Penix should have won the Heisman. Hope he wins the National Championship! Go Huskies! 💜 pic.twitter.com/E9CQ7ErDdp
— George Karl (@CoachKarl22) January 2, 2024
1 of the biggest robberies in heisman history !!! Penix is the best in the country
— Will Conroy (@CHILLCONROY) January 2, 2024
It’s OFFICIAL – Michael Penix is the biggest Heisman Snub in College Football History
The voters really chose the QB of a 9-3 team over a 13-0, undefeated CFP team just because one happened to play in the SEC…
Penix just went into Jayden Daniel’s state, & put on a bigger SHOW… pic.twitter.com/Q01dgGXtlO
— Blue Bloods Bias (@bluebloodsbias) January 2, 2024
So Penix was pretty much robbed of a Heisman huh???
— Danny Kanell (@dannykanell) January 2, 2024
https://twitter.com/A_G_Haubner/status/1742025057495589275
Michael Penix should have been the Heisman winner.
— Josh Furlong (@JFurKSL) January 2, 2024
Penix might be the biggest Heisman snub of all time.
— The GM of CFB (@cfbfrenzy22) January 2, 2024
One thing is very clear from last night:
Michael Penix Jr. is the biggest Heisman snub of all-time.
— ⭕️U – Woerzy (@woerzyfbaby) January 2, 2024
Been saying this for years, but reinforcing: It's absurd that the Heisman voting takes place before the most important games.
— Larry Williams (@LarryWilliamsTI) January 2, 2024
Michael Penix lost the Heisman and then played the best game of football the state of Louisiana saw this year pic.twitter.com/BdHrpT9Pcu
— Dustin Nickerson (@DustinNickerson) January 2, 2024
Once again. The Heisman trophy should be voted on after all games are played.
— Eric Mac Lain (@EricMacLain) January 2, 2024
Southern CFB fans finding out Penix is great all at the same time was hilarious! Of course he should’ve won the Heisman
— Sam (@Moorelife1) January 2, 2024
East coast/south Heisman voters seeing Michael Penix play for the first time. pic.twitter.com/cG4jiT5VMY
— Joe Fann (@Joe_Fann) January 2, 2024
I get that LSU fans were gonna mock anyone that said Michael Penix Jr deserved the Heisman over Jayden Daniels. I'd be right in there with them if LSU was my team.
But now that they're actually getting to see him play I hope they get it. He's the best passer in college football.
— Ralph Amsden (@ralphamsden) January 2, 2024
Can’t help wondering if Michael Penix Jr. would have won the Heisman Trophy were the votes cast after the College Football Playoff. Washington quarterback has been pinpoint plus tonight.
— Tim Sullivan (@TimSullivan714) January 2, 2024
If the Heisman waited until after the playoff, the winner would always be on a playoff team because recency bias is very real. However, people should not have needed this performance to vote for Penix https://t.co/u9wTxXp01J
— Dan Wolken (@DanWolken) January 2, 2024
Watching people across the nation realizing that Penix should have won the Heisman.
When people complain about East Coast and SEC bias, this is what we mean.— Marty Campbell (@MartyRCampbell) January 2, 2024